Tuesday , 29 July 2014
Breaking News
Home » Breaking News » Trial Update: Controversy Over Evidence Heats Up Defense
  NorCal Homes Team  Serving All of Your Davis  - El Macero - Woodland Real Estate Needs

Trial Update: Controversy Over Evidence Heats Up Defense

Yolo-Count-Court-Room-600By Justine Joya

The Stone case continued with the prosecutor calling Yolo County Deputy Coroner Laurel Weeks to the stand on the morning of May 2. Prosecuting Attorney Steve Mount conducted a cross-examination that began calmly but ended with an outburst by Defense Attorney Martha Sequeira.

Quentin Stone is the father accused of “shaking” his two-month-old baby, which potentially may have caused the baby’s death. The trial, which started last week, involves the contention that three-month-old Samuel Stone died from injuries that included bleeding in his brain, retinal hemorrhages and fractured ribs, and has left many questioning the charges at hand.

Before delving into the specifics of the victim’s case, the prosecution briefed the court on the witness’ occupation and expertise as a deputy coroner. As his examination continued, anticipation filled the air as the prosecution’s questions started to narrow in on Stone’s alleged victim. Asking the witness what her role was in the victim’s autopsy, she responded that she was in charge of photographing the body before, during, and after the procedures. When asked about any visible signs on the body, the witness informed the court that the body had a scar from the organ donating procedure and medical tags from the UC Davis Medical Center.

Mr. Mount then grabbed three documents from his seat and was re-approaching the witness when, before he was able to show the witness or the jurors the content of the documents, the defense interrupted with a boisterous “Objection!” Shortly after Ms. Sequeira proceeded to present her reasons for objecting, Judge Richardson called both counsels to the bench and requested a short recess. Once the jury evacuated the court room, the counsels and Judge Richardson were engaged in an intense discussion in which Ms. Sequeira was clearly vehement.

The documents that the prosecution was presenting were pictures of the victim’s fractured ribs. The defense argued that Mr. Mount violated the court’s ruling on the agreement made between both counsels. The agreement stated that both counsels would present all evidence and photos to each other before it was brought to the jurors’ attention. However, because both the defense and prosecution had access to the photos, Judge Richardson allowed the presentation of the photographs.

After the short recess, the prosecution revealed to the court three photographs of what appeared to be the victim’s fractured ribs. In further conducting his cross-examination, or at least attempting to, the defense made it very difficult for the prosecution to ask a question, which appeared to intimidate the witness, who began to second-guess her answers. To every question the prosecution asked, the defense followed up by objecting to it as “speculative,” “hearsay” or other objections.

When the prosecution finally delivered a question to the witness, it left a significant impression. He clarified through the witness that it was medical doctors who determined a victim’s cause of death, and that it was her job as a Deputy Coroner to determine the manner of death: suicide, homicide, accident, illness, or undetermined. DDA Mount asked her what, in her professional opinion, she noted the manner of death to be and she responded “homicide.”

Attempting to discredit the Deputy Coroner’s proficiency, Deputy Public Defender Sequeira questioned the witness about one of the requests made by the Stone family. The Stone family requested a Forensic Pediatric Pathologist to be present during the baby’s autopsy, but their request was not met. When the defense asked the witness why this was the case, she replied that the orders were made by her Chief Deputy and that she was simply following orders. The defense took a seat and stated “nothing further.”

Judge Richardson adjourned the court early afternoon on Friday, May 2 and scheduled the trial to be continued on Monday morning.

  NorCal Homes Team  Serving All of Your Davis  - El Macero - Woodland Real Estate Needs

About David Greenwald

David Greenwald is the founder, editor, and executive director of the Davis Vanguard. He founded the Vanguard in 2006. David Greenwald moved to Davis in 1996 to attend Graduate School at UC Davis in Political Science. He lives in South Davis with his wife Cecilia Escamilla Greenwald and three children.

40 comments

  1. sorry famous, but we can rule out any misdiagnosed illnesses or conditions. The doctor that just testified stated that he ruled everything out and tested for everything that he could possibly think of to rule out accidental vs non accidental death.

    • Elizabeth Bowler

      Dr Coulter also testified that the Vitamin D level was low, which is what you would expect to see in metabolic bone disease such as infantile rickets, so that is what I expect the defense will pursue when it is their turn

  2. Oops….that was in regards to Themis.

    But I will have a full updated article on todays testimony.

    I dont feel Mount is doing anything but his job as they all are.

    A bit of a solomne courtroom today…for some reason?

  3. No, Elizabeth, the vitamin D level had nothing to do with the cause if desth so.far. It was not low enough; per Pathologist s expert testimony.

    Brain showed several tramatic contusions.

    Lots more info in article, in am.

  4. Yes, I will read!

    I have to apologize in advance, I got real tired, had a singing gig with dad so I know my artucle suffers…lol.

    I hope at least most factual testimony is clear. But not my best, for sure…thanks for reading..

    I did forget to mention the doctor said the first thing he would have done if he knew the baby had fluid on brain was to remove it…….

  5. once again, we heard from another doctor, how draining the bloid and or fluid, may have posdibly changed the outcome……..this part bothers me the most…but, maybe its just from my own experience?

    still hard to hear.

Leave a Reply

Smackwagon Design - Building Relationships... "One Project at a TIME!"