Nooner Takes Plea, Will Be Released Just after Christmas

Lyle Nooner sits with his attorney Michelle Spaulding in court in August

The case of Lyle Nooner has taken some interesting twists and turns, but after pleading to an added fifth count on Wednesday, he will be released on December 27, two years after first being arrested in West Sacramento on drug and weapons charges.

Mr. Nooner, represented by Michelle Spaulding, plead no contest before Judge David Rosenberg to a violation of Health and Safety Code section 11370.1(a), possession of a controlled substance while armed.  With a prior strike, he received a two-year sentence that was doubled to four.  But because he has almost served for two years, he will not have to be transported to prison for additional time.

Michelle Spaulding told the Vanguard following the hearing, “I’m happy with what we did.  It was the best compromise that we could do in the situation we had.”

Overall, she said, “It was a tough case, there were a lot of issues.  I would have loved to have tried it but this was the second best outcome.”

Mr. Nooner was originally arraigned on December 30, 2016, on a five-count felony complaint including possession for sale of meth and heroin, and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.  Two of the counts were dismissed based on lack of Yolo County jurisdiction.

Mr. Nooner, 58, has a lengthy criminal history, having spent the better part of 24 years in prison after a 1985 conviction on concealed weapons charges.  However, since 2009 he had by most accounts cleaned himself up and was working with others in prison through the Inside Circle Foundation, which he started working with in Folsom.  According to a number of participants, Inner Circle helped turn their lives around and enabled many to get out of their cycle of crime.

The case attracted the attention of the Vanguard with extensive complaints by Ms. Spaulding that Mr. Nooner received physical abuse at the hands of jail staff, specifically corrections officers.  She filed a complaint with the county about his treatment.

On Wednesday, Ms. Spaulding told the Vanguard that Mr. Nooner has been interviewed by internal affairs.  She said that Nooner believes “they weren’t terribly interested in investigating it.”

“The physical conduct has stopped, he has not been harmed physically since the filing of the complaint,” she stated.  “They are however continuing to harass him in (other) ways.”

She said that jail staff for some reason believes he is able to walk.  “According to the medical records his knee is clearly injured,” she said.  “But they are doing things like taking his walker away and telling him he has to walk.”

Ms. Spaulding alleges they are now videotaping everything he does, including his conversations with counsel, which are by law confidential and, thus, staff is not permitted to record.

Upon his arrest in December of 2016, Mr. Nooner was injured.  He hurt his back, neck, knee, and his hand during the arrest.  “His hand was damaged to the point where it can’t be repaired.  He had physical therapy for months to get to the point where he could walk with a walker,” Michelle Spaulding claimed.  The injuries and incidents described here were relayed to the Vanguard through Ms. Spaulding, originating from her client Lyle Nooner.

According to his attorney, he had received roughly five significant beatings during the 16 months or so he has been at the Yolo County Jail, most of them because he talked back to a guard.

Ms. Spaulding explained that this incident occurred at one point and, according to Mr. Nooner, “since that time, the treatment from the guards has been has been no good whatsoever.”

For the most part, Mr. Nooner took the mistreatment in silence even though some of the beat downs were “pretty substantial” according to his attorney.

He had generally taken it, but “he said this time it was too bad, it hurt him too much and he needed it to stop.”

At approximately four in the morning on Saturday, June 9, there was a cell extraction.  The reason for their entry was a shroud covering a broken light fixture.  There are varying accounts as to the nature of this shroud.  Sheriff Ed Prieto told the Vanguard that it blocked the guards’ view of the cell, but Mr. Nooner, through his attorney, told the Vanguard that he covered the light with a very thin towel to shield it slightly in order to sleep.

There was a bare bulb on the ceiling where there was a huge crack or hole in the light cover, which stays on 24/7.  The guards had known about this shroud for months but did nothing until this night.

Ms. Spaulding explained, “He wanted me to also be clear that he covered the light with a very thin towel. It didn’t impede the light in anyway, he can still read by the light. And it had been up for quite some time and they left it up after the extraction. It’s still there.”

Mr. Nooner, through his attorney, claims that there were 10 officers involved in what happened next.  He has the names of six of them.  There may be a seventh name as well.

They came in talking about the shroud, and rolled him up.  They sat on him, kneeling on him, until finally, he explained to his attorney, his knee blew out.

In July, Ms. Spaulding filed a motion with the court to show cause after being denied access to her client multiple times over the weekend.  At the time, Deputy County Counsel stepped in to handle the matter.

On Wednesday, following the plea by Mr. Nooner, Deputy DA Matt De Moura dismissed counts one through four, for which Mr. Nooner would have faced up to 13 years in prison.  He will be sentenced on December 27 – at which point he will be released on probation.

—David M. Greenwald reporting

Inmate Alleges Yolo County Jail Staff Beat Him Multiple Times While at the Jail

Get Tickets To Vanguard’s Immigration Rights Event

Eventbrite - Immigration Law: Defending Immigrant Rights and Keeping Families Together

About The Author

David Greenwald is the founder, editor, and executive director of the Davis Vanguard. He founded the Vanguard in 2006. David Greenwald moved to Davis in 1996 to attend Graduate School at UC Davis in Political Science. He lives in South Davis with his wife Cecilia Escamilla Greenwald and three children.

Related posts


  1. Jim Hoch

    “he had received roughly five significant beatings during the 16 months or so he has been at the Yolo County Jail, most of them because he talked back to a guard”

    Maybe he should consider not doing that anymore?

    1. Howard P

      Interesting choice of the word “servants”, massa…

      But main point is valid… even those incarcerated have civil rights… if true, allegations point to uncivil, and wrongful behaviour…

  2. Ross Peabody

    Oh please. What are you, twelve?  The guards are public servants. You want me to say over militarized stormtroopers?  I could, but then I’d have to read ten paragraphs of Jeff M complaining that the police aren’t respected enough. Honestly, you’re right. If the allegations are true, it’s uncivil, wrongful, and also criminal.  You didn’t have to lead off your very salient point by being uncivil.

  3. Ross Peabody

    To be clear, before the pile on, I think that corrections workers are hard working underpaid people that are put in an impossible situation having a dangerous job, bosses that only care for profit and no resources. There’s respect there.  Still, there’s no justification to abuse the power they do have, violently or otherwise.

      1. David Greenwald

        Put it this way – mouthing off is not a good idea, he acknowledged that to his attorney. But beating someone is illegal. So I find it odd that you’re decision is to criticize the bad judgment as opposed to the illegal conduct – particularly when the illegal conduct is done under color of authority (allegedly).

        1. Jim Hoch

          I don’t know that any “illegal conduct” actually happened, that is just a claim by a his attorney at this point. I’m certainly not denying it but I put this in the category of “actions that are obviously stupid but perhaps are within your rights”.

  4. Howard P

    Before the release, the cops have all the access to a Nooner they could want… might get them in trouble tho’… (sorry, too easy, and if true, the treatment is indeed reprehensible and should be dealt with severely… that’s dead dog sirius  serious!)

  5. Joe Guy

    I was incarcerated with Mr. Nooner while he was in prison. He and I were at 2 prisons together. One at PVSP and CSATF. He was dealing drugs that were perscribed by medical staff for an “injury” that CDCR officers had inflicted on him. He was foul tempered and thought everyone owed him everything. Him mouthing off to correctional officers is nothing new. His hand they say is beyond repair was from a fight he used to brag about while he was in Folsom State prison. His knee they say is damaged was injured before he arrived at PVSP. He is playing the system!! Do I feel the police should have beat him, No! Its unjustified and under the color of authority wrong. But know this, he will be back out and up to his bag of tricks to get over on the system. He’s using old injuries to file a lawsuit to get paid. He was doing it while he was in prison and if the DA was smart enough to look through his CDCR C-file and his medical file, they would see that he’s playing the “game”. Obviously by my comment I do not like the guy, but if the allegations are correct that staff beat him, then by all means file a lawsuit. If they’re not…. Then he should be made to pay for those actions as well.

Leave a Reply

X Close

Newsletter Sign-Up

X Close

Monthly Subscriber Sign-Up

Enter the maximum amount you want to pay each month
Sign up for