SF District Attorney: Why Police Officers with Prior Misconduct Shouldn’t Be Trusted

Chesa Boudin speaking at a rally last August

By Ayanna Gandhi

SAN FRANCISCO – Chesa Boudin, San Francisco District Attorney, wrote an article for the New York Times on July 27, 2020, explaining why “[w]e shouldn’t trust the reports of officers with prior misconduct.” He believes that we must look to local prosecutors for police reform.

Boudin starts by writing, “The failure of both Congress and state legislatures to respond to the murder of George Floyd with any meaningful action reminds us that our nation’s attempts at reform can often amount to nothing. We need to look elsewhere for reform — to local prosecutors.

“As the police killings of Mr. Floyd, Breonna Taylor and Rayshard Brooks have demonstrated, the police typically don’t answer to the federal government or state legislatures; they are accountable to local prosecutors, who make decisions about if, when and how to charge officers. Demanding that prosecutors charge police officers who kill without justification is a crucial step, but it is only the beginning.”

The DA recognizes that everyone “knows what can happen when prosecutors get too cozy with the police. The refusal to prosecute the police after the deaths of Stephon Clark in Sacramento in 2018 and Sean Monterrosa in Vallejo, Calif., in June are just two local examples of the system’s failure.

“Similarly, it took intense public pressure before prosecutors brought tepid, third-degree murder charges against Derek Chauvin — later amended to second-degree murder — who kept his knee on George Floyd’s neck for nearly nine minutes, even though the case had compelling cellphone footage.”

The SF DA notes, “Local prosecutors must use the power and discretion afforded them to carry out sweeping reforms that will protect the public — especially Black communities — from police violence. Our system’s integrity depends on it.

“Prosecutors must do now what we should have done long ago: Prosecute offending officers and adopt measures that focus on increasing transparency, accountability and equal justice in a system plagued with impunity for the police and racial injustice. In order to fix the problems nationally, prosecutors should aim big, beyond our own agencies. The overwhelming majority of Americans support police reform.”

Boudin has strong feelings about the responsibility that prosecutors hold. He emphasizes his emotions and the importance of bringing officers to justice saying, “Prosecutors should also support the victims of police violence — regardless of whether the police acknowledge them as such. With few exceptions, the California Victim Compensation Board requires a police report listing the person harmed as a victim, which makes it unlikely, given current reporting practices, that victims of police violence receive benefits.

“I have partnered with other prosecutors to demand the board change this unjust policy, which leaves victims of police violence — and their families — to cover funeral and burial expenses on their own because police officers are the gatekeepers to compensation even in cases where they do the killing.”

Boudin unveiled a plan to start holding officers accountable, stating, “We should start with the basics: Police officers are unlikely to be held accountable if the prosecutors investigating and potentially prosecuting them feel indebted to them. And police unions remain one of the most powerful sponsors of prosecutor elections nationwide.

“Together with three other elected and former district attorneys, I recently pledged to never accept endorsements or contributions from law enforcement unions, and called on the California State Bar and the American Bar Association to cure this conflict of interest by prohibiting prosecutors from taking money or support directly from police unions.”

Additionally, he argues, “We created a policy requiring prosecutors to review police body camera footage before filing charges in any case that alleges resisting or assaulting an officer. Officers sometimes fabricate such charges against people on whom they used excessive force as a way to cover up their own misdeeds. If we prosecutors don’t watch the videos ourselves, we risk being complicit in prosecuting victims of police violence.”

The DA encourages DAs to expand “their victim services to include victims of police violence. We define who is a victim — not the police. And we must repair the wounds.”

DA Boudin claims he has already begun and believes, “Police reform will be more effective and durable with buy-in from prosecutors nationwide. As the recently elected district attorney of San Francisco, I have begun this work. Together with Shamann Walton, a San Francisco County supervisor, I drafted a resolution to prohibit hiring officers from other jurisdictions with prior misconduct findings — for things like excessive force, racial bias and dishonesty in reporting or investigating cases.

“Because of California’s Police Officer’s Bill of Rights, even as San Francisco’s district attorney I have no way of knowing how many of our police officers have histories of serious misconduct.”

However, while Boudin has made strides and is confident in his plan he recognizes that everyone “needs to do more. If police departments won’t remove officers who lack integrity, prosecutors should ensure that no one is prosecuted based on those officers’ unreliable accounts.

“Accordingly, my office will no longer charge cases that rely solely on uncorroborated reports from officers with prior serious misconduct. This policy — not to seek convictions on the word of individual officers whose testimony we have specific reason to doubt — will prevent wrongful convictions, deter future misconduct and build public trust.”

Boudin wraps up his piece on police and misconduct with an emotional call to action.

“Prosecutors must protect everyone — including communities of color that are often brutalized by those entrusted to keep them safe. Communities need to rethink prosecutors’ roles and demand proactive work to hold the police accountable and protect the public from police abuse. For decades, prosecutors have excused and sometimes perpetuated the systemic problems in our police forces. Now it is time for us to stand up and accept responsibility for fixing them,” he said.

To sign up for our new newsletter – Everyday Injustice – https://tinyurl.com/yyultcf9

Enter the maximum amount you want to pay each month
Sign up for


About The Author

The Vanguard Court Watch operates in Yolo, Sacramento and Sacramento Counties with a mission to monitor and report on court cases. Anyone interested in interning at the Courthouse or volunteering to monitor cases should contact the Vanguard at info(at)davisvanguard(dot)org - please email info(at)davisvanguard(dot)org if you find inaccuracies in this report.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

X Close

Newsletter Sign-Up

X Close

Monthly Subscriber Sign-Up

Enter the maximum amount you want to pay each month
Sign up for