Missouri County Jail Faces Lawsuit Alleging Inhumane Conditions, Inadequate Medical Care


By Evie Sun

FARMINGTON, MO – Pretrial detainees endured unconstitutional, discriminatory, and dangerous conditions at the St. Francois County Jail in Farmington, MO, according to a complaint filed Monday by the Simon Law Firm, Vonne Karraker and Vincent Colianni.

The lawsuit names St. Francois County, Sheriff Dan Bullock, Advanced Correctional Healthcare, Inc., former Jail Administrator Dennis Smith, and jail nurse Heather Smith as defendants, charging they systematically and knowingly denied “the minimal necessities to individuals confined at the St. Francois County jail by subjecting them to appalling and inhumane conditions.”

The suit also alleges defendants were deliberately indifferent to detainees’ medical, mental health, and dental needs and discriminated against people with disabilities.

“The conditions that our clients and several others endured while detained at the St. Francois County Jail is nothing short of cruel and inhumane,” said Corrigan Lewis, Staff Attorney at ArchCity Defenders.

The complaint details how plaintiffs Hopple, Rudigier, and Mesey were subjected to the following unsanitary and unlawful conditions: overflowing sewage, black mold, and unhygienic conditions, inadequate medical care, overcrowding, inadequate staffing, violence, and retaliation from St. Francois County Jail Staff, extreme cold, and discrimination against people with disabilities.

Plaintiff Hopple was a pretrial detainee in the St. Francois County Jail from May 4, 2018 to on or around Oct. 23, 2018. During his time, he reported facing overcrowded conditions in his holding cell, unsanitary conditions that complicated his ability to maintain adequate hygiene, and lack of access to adequate food.

According to factual allegations detailed in the lawsuit, “Mr. Hopple saw thick black mold and slime on the walls and floors of the showers. The toilets would regularly overflow, and there was a lingering smell of sewage.”

During the last few weeks of Hopple’s detention in Oct. 2018, “the temperature outside dropped to below freezing. However, deputies refused to turn the heat on because they felt it was too early in the year to do so.”

Mr. Hopple also experienced and witnessed deputy cruelty throughout his detention.

“Mr. Hopple recalls one situation where the deputies signaled the detainees to exit their cells by switching the lights on and off. One of Mr. Hopple’s fellow detainees was blind and could not understand the deputy’s instructions to exit his cell. When the individual did not follow the order, deputies entered the man’s cell and maced him,” according to the complaint.

Ms. Rudigier was a pretrial detainee from on or about March 5, 2017, to on or about March 3, 2019. She was denied medication for her mental illness for 21 of her nearly 24 months of pretrial detention.

Throughout her detention, she also reported experiencing “severe abdominal pain and unusual vaginal discharge.” She requested medical assistance…and was prescribed antibiotics. However, after several rounds of antibiotics, her pain and discomfort continued.

According to allegations in the lawsuit, “When Ms. Rudigier was finally able to see a physician, outside of the jail, she was diagnosed with a gallbladder issue that required emergency medical surgery.”

Mr. Mesey was a pretrial detainee from on or about Oct. 19, 2017, to on or about Sept. 13, 2018; on or about July 30, 2018, to on or about August 4, 2018; Oct. 30 to Oct. 31, 2018; and on or about April 11, 2019, to on or about May 2, 2019.

He was born with a mobility impairment that causes substantial limitations in his daily living activities. However, according to allegations, “Each and every time that Mr. Mesey requested an accommodation, it was denied by deputies. As a result, Mr. Mesey struggled to walk, climb stairs, or bathe without pain while
detained at the St. Francois County Jail.”

Mesey also received inadequate medical care during his detention at the St. Francois County Jail. He developed a toothache that required medical attention during his detention between Dec. 2017 and Jan. 2018, but was refused requests for pain medication.

According to the lawsuit, “Mr. Mesey began receiving adequate health care only when he was transferred to the custody of the Missouri Department of Corrections (DOC) in June 2018. At that point in time, Mr. Mesey’s tooth was so seriously decayed it had to be extracted.”

Since 2005, 27 cases have been filed in the Eastern District of Missouri regarding allegations of physical violence, denial of medical care, lack of food, overcrowding and more.

“Nothing that has happened so far has felt like justice for the people who have been in the jail, for their loved ones, or the people on the sidelines who are appalled by the lack of accountability,” said Vonne Karraker, an attorney with Malaney, Karraker and Karrake. “This government has spoiled the reputation of the county and it’s devastating.”

Evie Sun is a third-year student at UCLA, studying Sociology. She is from the East Bay Area.

To sign up for our new newsletter – Everyday Injustice – https://tinyurl.com/yyultcf9

Support our work – to become a sustaining at $5 – $10- $25 per month hit the link:


About The Author

The Vanguard Court Watch operates in Yolo, Sacramento and Sacramento Counties with a mission to monitor and report on court cases. Anyone interested in interning at the Courthouse or volunteering to monitor cases should contact the Vanguard at info(at)davisvanguard(dot)org - please email info(at)davisvanguard(dot)org if you find inaccuracies in this report.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

X Close

Newsletter Sign-Up

X Close

Monthly Subscriber Sign-Up

Enter the maximum amount you want to pay each month
Sign up for