Court Watch In Search of Council Members

Vanguard Court Watch of Yolo County is seeking applications from members of the community to become committee members for a newly-formed Vanguard Court Watch Council.

Vanguard Court Watch of Yolo County is seeking applications from members of the community to become committee members for a newly-formed Vanguard Court Watch Council.
By Catherine McKnight and Antoinnette BorbonOn Friday, January 18, 2013, the further jury trial for People v. Sonne continued. Thaddeus Sonne is being charged on a count of rape by force, pertaining to an incident that occurred in downtown Davis on the night of August 16, 2012.
Deputy Public Defender Dan Hutchinson presented a case that raises more questions about whether a jury can reasonably come to a verdict that this was rape by force, or if this really was a consensual matter between two intoxicated young adults.
By Stephanie Yang Day two of the Medel trial revealed several pieces of evidence that sheds light on the three different burglaries that occurred in the summer of 2011 in Davis. Witnesses who confirmed the evidence included police officers and detectives from the city of Davis, and bystanders from the time of the burglaries.
On July 14, 2011, at the time of the defendant’s arrest, the police found the defendant’s SUV filled with property. This was the same dark-colored SUV with the same license plate that was reported to be at all three burglaries.
by Antoinnette Borbon On August 16, 2012, two 20-year-old residents of UC Davis started partying by the pool and later ended up in downtown Davis for “Thursday Night Party Night.” After drinking enough alcohol to reach more than double the legal limit for driving a motor vehicle, the two young adults decide to end their evening at the bar/restaurant called Our House near the train station.
Two Davis police officers responded to a call near Tres Hermanas in downtown Davis, also near the train depot. While they were on the scene, a bystander told them there was a couple that appeared to be engaged in sexual intercourse near the train tracks.
On Tuesday, we ran what was largely the view of Kelle Huston, who believed that her family was subjected to undue harassment from the authorities. Bolstering her point were the large number of probation searches on her property, which resulted in one relatively small case of marijuana possession and another case where some individuals attempted to sell marijuana, which ended up in a plea agreement.
However, in addition to several people posting contrasting information on the Vanguard, we received an account from one neighbor who had a very different view, believing that the article “badly missed the mark.”
By Vanguard Court Watch InternsThe trial of People v. Jimmy Medel began on Tuesday, January 15 with opening statements by Deputy District Attorney Johnson and Public Defender Olson. Mr. Medel is charged with 3 counts of residential burglary in Davis, during the summer of 2011. One incident occurred on June 22 and the others on July 13 and 14.
A similar, dark-colored SUV and portions of the license plate number were identified by witnesses in all 3 incidents. Several of the witnesses saw a Hispanic male removing items from the homes and leaving the crime scenes.
This past week, the local newspaper featured an article on one of the top professional skaters in the world, Nyjah Huston, who also happens to be a native of Davis. Mr. Huston, who just turned 18, is using his fame to help people less fortunate than he.
Writes the Davis Enterprise, “In 2008, Nyjah and his mother Kelle Huston formed a nonprofit called Let it Flow, which raised enough money to build a well in Ethiopia. Now, the Hustons have a new Indiegogo.com campaign that aims to raise funds by Jan. 18 to build four more wells in African countries such as Ethiopia, Kenya and Tanzania.”
By Dan AielloCiting California Governor Edmund G. “Jerry” Brown, Jr.’s veto last session of a bill that would have allowed reporters access to prisoners protesting conditions within the state’s 33 prisons, reform advocates called on judges, legislators and news media to ignore Brown’s claim that the state’s prison crisis “is over.”
The Brown administration began the week in court with a motion before the 9th Circuit Federal to vacate the population cap imposed on the state’s overcrowded prisons, citing the state’s realignment plan as evidence the cap is both dangerous and no longer needed.
By Vanguard Court Watch InternsSteven Lopez, an inmate at the Yolo County Jail, had his sentencing hearing this past Friday, January 11th. He has been charged on four counts, mainly pertaining to theft and unauthorized use of vehicles. While the counts he has been charged with are not something to be particularly curious about, this case embodies the stigma all too often placed upon these “criminals.”
While in custody, Mr. Lopez started hysterically crying to Judge Mock of Department 3. Although I am certain this is not uncommon in the courtroom, it is cases like this that shed light on the indisputable truth that many people seem to forget – that those in custody are human just like the rest of us.
Just before the New Year, we ran our Sunday Commentary, “When Speaking Out Comes with a Price,” where we discussed Jann Murray-Garcia’s concerns about accepting an invitation from Chief Deputy District Attorney Jonathan Raven to join their new Multi-Cultural Community Council, an invitation he made public at the December 1 Breaking the Silence of Racism event.
Dr. Murray-Garcia had several times declined the offer, and told him so publicly. She wrote, “I told Jonathan I was not interested, because I had accompanied too many Davis folks in Yolo County Superior Court who were inappropriately charged, investigated, overcharged, gang-labeled and unnecessarily prosecuted at great taxpayers’ (yours and mine) expense, and residents’ turmoil.”
Editor’s Note: Every week, the Vanguard Court Watch of Yolo County sends a number of interns into the Yolo County Court in Woodland. Beginning today, we will be publishing some of their accounts of what they have observed.
Many of these are collaborative efforts and will be published under the byline of Vanguard Court Watch Intern. Others will be published under the intern’s individual name. This feature will at least be published on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays.
From the start, defense attorneys argued the case against Israel Covarrubias and Amaris Rodriguez stemming from a May 2010 arrest in Davis should be a marijuana case. But for nearly two and a half years, the Yolo County DA’s office held the couple to answer to four criminal counts. These included the sale of marijuana, possession of marijuana for sale, conspiracy to commitment a crime, and the standalone Penal Code section 186.22(a) charge for criminal street gang activity, along with three gang enhancements, from Penal Code section 186.22(b).
All told, the co-defendants faced 13 years in prison if convicted. The defense attorneys all along argued that this case was really a marijuana sale case and should be charged as such.
Governor Brown Issues Poignant Demand to End Federal Oversight of California’s Prisons- “The prison emergency is over in California,” Governor Jerry Brown declared during a pointed press conference on Tuesday.He told reporters, “California is a powerful state, we can run our own prisons. And by God, let those judges give us our prisons back. We’ll run them right.”
By Will Matthews and Rebecca McCrayA recent study from the Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice (CJCJ) demonstrates that decriminalization of marijuana can actually improve our children’s futures while saving taxpayers billions of dollars.
In 2011, Senate Bill 1449 was implemented, which reduced the punishment for simple marijuana possession from a misdemeanor criminal offense to a civil infraction punishable by a fine of no more than $100. Data from the California Department of Justice’s Criminal Justice Statistics Center for 2011 reveals an impressive 20 percent decrease in overall youth arrests in the state compared to the previous year, and a 60 percent decrease in marijuana arrests. The CJCJ analysis determined that the “largest contributor to [the overall] decrease was a drop of 9,000 in youths’ low-level marijuana possession arrests” since the passage of SB 1449.
We are closing the seventh calendar year of the existence of the Davis Vanguard. In some ways, our mission has changed over that period of time, but in fundamental ways, we remain the same with the idea of providing the alternative voice to the discourse provided in more mainstream publications.
The future of the death penalty in California could not be more murky. In November, the voters had a chance to end the death penalty in the state, but Prop. 34 was narrowly defeated, 52 percent to 48 percent. That leaves the system still alive, technically, though on life support.

The case of Marco Topete began in June of 2008, when the parolee led Sheriff’s Deputy Tony Diaz on a high-speed chase that ultimately ended with the tragic shooting of the sheriff’s deputy.
From the time Mr. Topete was arrested and the time that reporters and the public were locked out of the Yolo County Courtroom, until the jury ultimately reached the verdict during the penalty phase to impose the death penalty – there were numerous twists and turns.
Commentary: Awhile back, after Richard Hirschfield was convicted of killing two young UC Davis students over 30 years ago, someone suggested that we focus on honoring the victims.
As Bob Dunning wrote last weekend in his column, “Not only did he take the lives of two of Davis’ finest, he also sentenced their parents and siblings and extended families to a lifetime of agony that simply never ends. He wounded the soul of this town and shook us to our core, and those of us who lived here then will never forget that horrible time.”
One of the more interesting questions has emerged in the sweethearts murder trial, in which Richard Hirschfield, 32 years later, was finally convicted of the murders of two UC Davis students in December 1980. With the special circumstances conviction, Mr. Hirschfield is now eligible for the death penalty.
But given Mr. Hirschfield’s age, the state of the death penalty system, and the length of time it takes to bring a case from prosecution to execution, even under the best of circumstances, there is simply no way that the convicted killer will ever be executed.
They stood last week in front of the Yolo County Courthouse, a few mothers, less than a month after their sons had been convicted of attempted murder as they shot into an inhabited dwelling. With the enhancements, it is likely that their sons face 35 to life.
German Vizcarra, 19, Juan Reyes, 21, and Rolando Arismendez, 38, had their trial in late October and were found guilty on all counts.